FERNTREE GULLY STAR MAIL
Home » Opinion » FILM REVIEW: Oscars nominations and snubs

FILM REVIEW: Oscars nominations and snubs

This week, Seth Lukas Hynes looks at which movies got the nod and which were snubbed at the Oscars.

The 2023 Oscars are just under a month away, and should be a very interesting ceremony.

As with the South Korean film Parasite in 2019, the German film All Quiet on the Western Front was nominated for both Best International Feature and Best Picture. Everything Everywhere All At Once received a whopping eleven nominations, and with Daniel Kwan and Daniel Scheinert nominated together for Best Director, this is a rare instance of more than one director nominated for the same film. Brendan Fraser was nominated for Best Actor for The Whale; even the nomination is a major triumph in his career resurgence. Several Asian actors were nominated, namely Michelle Yeoh, Ke Huy Quan and Stephanie Hsu for Everything Everywhere All At Once and Hong Chau for The Whale. Angela Bassett, who had a powerful supporting role in Black Panther: Wakanda Forever, became the first actor nominated for a Marvel Cinematic Universe performance.

The little-known drama To Leslie saw an Academy investigation into a possible breach of lobbying rules. While the celebrity promotion of To Leslie was widely criticised, no formal complaints were made and the Academy found no wrongdoing on star Andrea Riseborough’s part, so her Best Actress nomination was retained.

There were some puzzling snubs this year. Scott Derrickson deserved a Best Director nomination for the compelling, taut, multi-layered The Black Phone. Nope was a fun, fascinating film with great performances from Keke Palmer and Daniel Kaluuya, eerie sound design and remarkable effects. The Menu’s dark wit deserved an Original Screenplay nomination. To me, the most baffling snub was Three Thousand Years of Longing: this poignant, entrancing film at the very least deserved a Production Design nomination.

I hope you enjoy watching the Oscars, and I hope you’re satisfied with the results.

– Seth Lukas Hynes

Digital Editions


  • Murder mystery marathon

    Murder mystery marathon

    Lilydale Athenaeum Theatre The Games Afoot Or Homes for the Holidays us a farce murder mystery. A “Who Dunnit” set in 1936 where the famous…

More News

  • One family, three generations, one school

    One family, three generations, one school

    Purchase this photo from Pic Store: 530156 Next week, three generations of the same family will walk through the gates of Monbulk Primary School together, a rare and special moment…

  • Cockatoo teen wins Young Citizen of the Year

    Cockatoo teen wins Young Citizen of the Year

    At just 18, Eliza Owen from Cockatoo has already saved lives, rebuilt hope, and inspired a community. Last night, the Cardinia Shire Council recognised her extraordinary efforts, naming her Young…

  • Fighting for the vulnerable, Ferny Creek local honoured

    Fighting for the vulnerable, Ferny Creek local honoured

    A Ferny Creek local has been recognised for his outstanding public service to the disability and social services sectors across Victoria, receiving the Public Service Medal for 2026. Living quietly…

  • Increasing events, outages prompt push to implement temporary disaster roaming

    Increasing events, outages prompt push to implement temporary disaster roaming

    With disasters seeming to become more frequent and severe in Australia, ensuiring our telecommunications are capable of keeping us connected in a crisis is crucial. Casey MP and Shadow Assistant…

  • Community leader recognised

    Community leader recognised

    A dedicated Hills community volunteer has been recognised for his long-standing commitment to connection, wellbeing and inclusion. Mr Heath Pawley was set to receive the Ian De La Rue Award…

  • Belgrave paramedic awarded Ambulance Service Medal

    Belgrave paramedic awarded Ambulance Service Medal

    Belgrave paramedic educator Jessica Joy Drummond has been awarded the Ambulance Service Medal (ASM) for distinguished service as a member of an Australian ambulance service. Ms Drummond, who has served…

  • The Ranges’ very own Wildlife Warrior

    The Ranges’ very own Wildlife Warrior

    Yarra Ranges Council’s Citizen of the Year Award goes to wildlife warrior Emma Sullivan. Having run the Wattle Wildlife Shelter in the Dandenong Ranges for many years, which provides a…

  • Gordon Buller awarded for a lifetime’s worth of devotion

    Gordon Buller awarded for a lifetime’s worth of devotion

    One of the Yarra River’s most determined protectors, Gordon Buller, received the Mayor’s Lifetime Achievement Award for the Australia Day Civic Awards. Mr Buller was recognised for his tireless commitment…

  • Summer fun keeps arty kids cool

    Summer fun keeps arty kids cool

    Purchase this photo from Pic Store: 530496 Kids kept cool and creative over summer at the Belgrave Library with the help of a locally based artist and educator in some…

  • Many lifetimes of achievement recognised in Australia Day Awards

    Many lifetimes of achievement recognised in Australia Day Awards

    Volunteers striving to improve the world around them have been recognised in this year’s Australia Day Civic Awards, with nominees awarded in a ceremony on Monday 26 January. The awards,…